A Will is normally revoked in whole or in part by a declaration to that effect in a later Will/Codicil, but what if you want to revoke the Will but do not want to make a new one either?
Under Section 20 of the Wills Act 1837, a Will may be revoked by “burning, tearing or otherwise destroying the same by the testator or by some person in his presence and by his direction with the intention of revoking the same”. There are two elements required under the law:
1. Symbolic destruction
Physical destruction is required. Simply striking through the Will with a pen or crossing out wording or writing “revoked” across the Will is not sufficient. That said, if a vital part (e.g. the signature) is destroyed, this partial destruction may be held to revoke the entire Will. If the part destroyed is less substantial, then the partial destruction may revoke only that part that was actually destroyed. The test is whether the remainder of the Will is intelligible and can still operate in the absence of the destroyed part.
The destruction must be carried out by the testator themselves or by someone else in the testator’s presence and by their direction.
2. Intention to revoke
The testator must have the intention to revoke, so a Will destroyed by accident is not revoked. Where a Will has been destroyed, but not successfully revoked, the Court will look at evidence to establish the contents of the Will. The best evidence would be a copy of the original Will. However, it may be necessary to look at other evidence, such as oral evidence from those involved in drawing up the Will, the draft or previous version of the Will, and circumstantial evidence like the relationship between the testator and the beneficiaries.
Cheese v Lovejoy (1877) 2 PD 251
Facts
Several years after making his Will, the testator put a line through various parts of it. He then wrote “This is revoked” on the back of the Will and threw it into a pile of waste paper in his room. The Will was retrieved by the testator’s servant, who placed it on the table of the kitchen and left it lying there till the testator’s death 7-8 years afterwards.
Decision
The Court held that the Will was not revoked because Section 20 of the Wills Act 1837 requires both destruction and intention to revoke. Here the testator clearly intended to revoke the Will, but he had not destroyed it. The judge said:
“All the destroying in the world without intention will not revoke a will, nor all the intention in the world without destroying; there must be the two.”
Also, the testator must have testamentary capacity to form the intention to revoke the Will, the same degree of mental capacity being required as for making a Will, and the Will must be deliberately destroyed. Therefore, destruction, when the testator is of unsound mind, does not revoke a Will, like for example when the testator is:
- Drunk or intoxicated;
- In a fit of madness; and
- Acting on any assumption of fact which proves false.
Comment
As you can see, revoking your own Will is not as easy as it seems. The common way to revoke your Will, and arguably the simplest, is to have a new Will drafted and ensure it is executed correctly.
How can we help?
Ronny Tang is an Associate in our expert Dispute Resolution team.
If you need any advice, please do not hesitate to contact Ronny or another member of the team in Derby, Leicester, or Nottingham on 0800 024 1976 or via our online enquiry form.
Contact us