Parental responsibility is a foundational legal concept in family law that encompasses the rights, duties, and authority a parent has regarding their child’s upbringing. While the law generally presumes that maintaining both parents’ involvement serves a child’s best interests, there are circumstances where removing parental responsibility becomes necessary for the child’s welfare and protection. This article considers the legal framework, grounds, and procedures to remove parental responsibility from a father in England and Wales, with particular focus on when such action may be appropriate and the Court processes involved.
Understanding Parental Responsibility
Parental responsibility refers to the legal rights, duties, powers, and responsibilities a parent has in relation to their child. For fathers, parental responsibility is automatically acquired if:
- He was married to the child’s mother at the time of birth
- He is named on the birth certificate (for births registered after December 1, 2003)
- He has obtained a Parental Responsibility Agreement with the mother
- He has secured a Parental Responsibility Order from the Court
- He has been appointed as the child’s guardian
- He has obtained a Child Arrangements Order specifying the child lives with him
When Removal of Parental Responsibility May Be Considered
Removing parental responsibility is a significant legal step that Courts do not take lightly. It is important to understand that the threshold for removing parental responsibility is deliberately high, as the Courts generally believe that maintaining both parents’ involvement serves a child’s best interests.
However, removal may be considered in exceptional circumstances such as:
- Serious abuse or neglect: Where there is evidence that the father has physically, emotionally, or sexually abused the child, or has allowed such abuse to occur.
- Persistent failure in parental duties: Where the father has consistently failed to fulfil his responsibilities towards the child over an extended period.
- Risk of significant harm: Where allowing the father to retain parental responsibility poses an ongoing risk to the child’s physical or emotional wellbeing.
- Complete absence from the child’s life: Where the father has been entirely absent from the child’s life for a significant period with no attempt at contact or involvement.
- Extremely damaging behaviour: Where the father’s actions or behaviour are deemed extremely detrimental to the child’s development and welfare.
- Criminal convictions: Particularly those involving offences against children or domestic abuse.
How to Remove Parental Responsibility from a Father – The Legal Process
Step 1: Determine Eligibility to Apply
Only certain individuals can apply to remove a father’s parental responsibility:
- The child’s mother
- The child (with court permission)
- A guardian
- A person who already has parental responsibility for the child
- A local authority in specific circumstances
Step 2: Identify the Appropriate Application
The type of application depends on how the father obtained parental responsibility:
- For unmarried fathers named on the birth certificate: Application to terminate parental responsibility
- For fathers with a Parental Responsibility Agreement or Order: Application to discharge the agreement or order
- For married fathers: The process is more complex as their parental responsibility can only be terminated through adoption or parental order proceedings, however the Court can make Orders which limit the father’s exercise of his parental responsibility if this is considered necessary to protect the child’s welfare.
Step 3: Prepare Court Application
The application must include:
- A completed C1 form (Application under the Children Act 1989)
- A C1A form if there are allegations of harm or domestic abuse
- Supporting evidence documenting reasons for the application
- The appropriate Court fee (or fee exemption application)
Step 4: Court Considerations
When reviewing an application to remove parental responsibility, the Court’s paramount consideration is the welfare of the child. The Court will assess:
- The circumstances in which the father acquired parental responsibility
- The father’s commitment to the child
- The attachment between father and child
- The father’s reasons for contesting the application (if applicable)
- Any risk factors associated with the father retaining parental responsibility
- The potential impact on the child of removing parental responsibility
Step 5: Court Hearing
Both parties will be expected to attend Court hearings. The Court may:
- Request additional evidence or reports
- Ask for input from CAFCASS (Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service)
- Consider the child’s wishes and feelings, depending on their age and understanding
- Order temporary arrangements while the case is ongoing
The Child’s Welfare Principle
Throughout the legal process, the Court’s primary focus remains the welfare of the child. This is assessed through the ‘welfare checklist’ which includes:
- The child’s wishes and feelings (considered in light of age and understanding)
- The child’s physical, emotional, and educational needs
- The likely effect on the child of any change in circumstances
- The child’s age, sex, background, and any characteristics the court considers relevant
- Any harm the child has suffered or is at risk of suffering
- The capability of each parent to meet the child’s needs
- The range of powers available to the court
Alternative Options to Consider
Before pursuing the removal of parental responsibility, less drastic alternatives may be worth exploring:
- Specific Issue Orders or Prohibited Steps Orders: These can limit how parental responsibility is exercised without removing it entirely.
- Child Arrangements Orders: These can specify residence and contact arrangements while maintaining parental responsibility.
- Undertakings or agreements: In some cases, the father may agree to restrict how he exercises parental responsibility.
- Supervised contact: This allows the relationship to continue in a controlled environment where the child’s safety can be ensured.
Professional Legal Support
Given the complexity and emotional nature of these proceedings, seeking professional legal advice is crucial. Our experienced family law solicitors can:
- Assess the specific circumstances of your case
- Advise on the likelihood of success
- Help prepare the necessary documentation
- Represent you throughout the court process
- Offer support and guidance at every stage
Conclusion
Removing parental responsibility from a father is a significant legal step that Courts approach with caution. The process requires substantial evidence demonstrating that such removal serves the child’s best interests.
Each case is unique and is assessed on its individual merits, with the welfare of the child remaining the paramount consideration. If you are considering this course of action, we recommend seeking tailored legal advice to understand the options available and the most appropriate approach for your specific circumstances.
Contact Us
Rina Mistry is a specialist family law solicitor at Nelsons.
If you need advice on any children law-related matter or have any other family law-related queries, please contact us. We will be happy to discuss your circumstances in more detail and give you more information about the services that our family law solicitors can provide, along with details of our hourly rates and fixed fee services.
For more information or advice, please call Rina or another member of our team in Derby, Leicester or Nottingham on 0800 024 1976 or contact us via our online form.
Contact us