One of the most frequently asked questions we encounter is whether someone holding a Power of Attorney can change another person’s Will. It’s a crucial question that touches on fundamental principles of personal autonomy, mental capacity, and estate planning. The answer is nuanced and depends on several important legal factors.
The Short Answer: Generally No, But There Are Exceptions
In most circumstances, a person holding Power of Attorney cannot change or make a new Will on behalf of the person who granted them that power (known as the ‘donor’). However, there are specific, limited circumstances where this may be possible through Court intervention.
Understanding Powers of Attorney
A Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) is a legal document that allows you to appoint someone you trust to make decisions on your behalf if you lose mental capacity in the future. You must be 18 or over and have mental capacity (the ability to make your own decisions) when you make your LPA.
There are two types of LPA:
- Property and Financial Affairs LPA: This allows your attorney to make decisions about your money, property, and financial matters.
- Health and Welfare LPA: This covers decisions about your personal care, medical treatment, and where you live.
Why Attorneys Usually Cannot Change Wills
The fundamental principle is that Will-making is an intensely personal act that requires the individual to have testamentary capacity at the time the Will is made. This means they must:
- Understand what a Will is and its effects
- Understand the nature and extent of their estate
- Understand the claims others might have on their estate
- Be free from any mental disorder that might influence their decisions
But, this is only if you’re not ‘of sound mind’ and are incapable of doing it yourself. Even with an LPA, attorneys cannot simply decide to change someone’s Will based on their own judgment about what would be best.
The Court of Protection Exception
There is one significant exception to this general rule. If someone lacks mental capacity and there are compelling reasons why their Will should be changed, an application can be made to the Court of Protection for what’s called a “Statutory Will.”
When Might the Court Consider Making a Statutory Will?
The Court of Protection may authorise a new Will in circumstances such as:
- Changed circumstances: The person’s financial situation has changed dramatically since their last Will was made
- Tax efficiency: Changes in tax law mean the current Will would result in unnecessary tax liabilities
- Family changes: Marriages, divorces, births, or deaths in the family that the person would likely have wanted to reflect in their Will
- Inadequate provision: The current Will makes inadequate provision for someone the person would want to benefit
The High Legal Bar
The Court sets an extremely high bar for Statutory Wills. They must be satisfied that:
- The person lacks capacity to make a Will themselves
- The proposed will reflects what the person would have wanted if they had capacity
- The changes are in the person’s best interests
- All relevant parties have been consulted
This is not a decision the Court takes lightly, and the process is typically lengthy and expensive.
What Attorneys Can Do Instead
While attorneys generally cannot change Wills, they do have other important powers and responsibilities:
- Financial Management: Property and financial affairs attorneys can manage investments, pay bills, and make financial decisions to preserve and potentially grow the estate.
- Healthcare Decisions: Health and welfare attorneys can make decisions about medical treatment and care arrangements that may indirectly affect the person’s financial position.
- Estate Preservation: Attorneys can take steps to preserve the estate’s value and ensure assets are managed appropriately until the person’s death.
Practical Considerations for Families
If You’re Creating an LPA
When setting up your LPA, consider these important points:
- Choose trustees carefully: Select attorneys who understand your values and would make decisions you’d be comfortable with.
- Provide guidance: While not legally binding, you can include guidance in your LPA about your preferences and values.
- Regular reviews: Review your Will and LPA regularly to ensure they work together effectively and reflect your current circumstances.
- Professional advice: Always seek professional legal advice when creating these important documents.
If You’re an Attorney
If you’re acting as an attorney and believe the person’s Will no longer reflects their best interests:
- Seek legal advice: Don’t attempt to change anything without proper legal guidance.
- Document concerns: Keep detailed records of why you believe changes might be necessary.
- Consider all options: Explore whether the person might regain capacity to make changes themselves.
- Court application: If necessary, seek advice about applying to the Court of Protection for a Statutory Will.
Common Misconceptions
- “I have LPA, so I can do anything”: Having Power of Attorney doesn’t give you unlimited power. You must always act in the person’s best interests and within the scope of your authority.
- “Family members can decide together”: Even if all family members agree, you cannot simply change someone’s Will without proper legal authority.
- “It’s obviously what they would have wanted”: Personal opinions about what someone would have wanted are not sufficient legal grounds for changing a Will.
Protecting Against Abuse
The restrictions on changing Wills through Power of Attorney exist to protect vulnerable people from exploitation. However, there are additional safeguards:
- Office of the Public Guardian: This body monitors attorneys and investigates concerns about abuse of power.
- Court oversight: In serious cases, the Court of Protection can intervene to protect someone’s interests.
- Professional obligations: Solicitors and other professionals have duties to report suspected abuse.
Planning Ahead: Prevention is Better Than Cure
The best approach is to plan ahead while you have full mental capacity:
- Regular Will reviews: Review your Will every few years or after major life changes.
- Flexible provisions: Consider including flexible provisions in your Will that can adapt to changing circumstances.
- Trust structures: In complex situations, Trust structures might provide more flexibility than a simple Will.
- Professional advice: Regular consultations with legal professionals can help ensure your estate planning remains appropriate.
When to Seek Legal Advice
You should seek immediate legal advice if:
- You’re an attorney who believes a Will needs changing
- You’re concerned that an attorney is overstepping their bounds
- There are family disputes about inheritance while someone lacks capacity
- You need to understand the interaction between LPAs and Wills
- You’re considering applying for a Statutory Will
The Importance of Professional Guidance
Estate planning and Power of Attorney arrangements are complex legal areas where mistakes can have serious consequences. At Nelsons, our experienced Wills and Probate team regularly advises families navigating these challenging situations.
We understand that these issues often arise during difficult times when families are dealing with a loved one’s declining health or capacity. Our approach is to provide clear, practical advice while being sensitive to the emotional challenges families face.
Conclusion
While Power of Attorney provides important protections and decision-making authority, it does not generally extend to changing Wills. The law maintains strict boundaries to protect personal autonomy and prevent abuse. However, in exceptional circumstances, the Court of Protection may authorise changes through Statutory Wills.
The key is proper planning while you have capacity, choosing attorneys carefully, and seeking professional legal advice when questions arise. By understanding these boundaries and planning appropriately, you can help ensure your wishes are respected and your loved ones are protected.
If you’re dealing with questions about Power of Attorney and Wills, don’t navigate these complex waters alone. Our expert team at Nelsons is here to guide you through the process and ensure your family’s interests are properly protected.
Get in Touch
Bianca Gregory is a Legal Executive in our expert Wills and Probate team. She specialises in the administration of estates, Inheritance Tax planning, Wills, and Lasting Powers of Attorney.
If you would like more information or advice on Wills, LPAs & Trusts or would like to arrange a meeting with Bianca or another member of the team in Derby, Leicester or Nottingham, please contact us on 0808 239 3916 or via our online enquiry form.