Settlement Does Not Prevent Will Challenge

When a dependant of a deceased person is unexpectedly not provided for under the will, the normal course of action is to bring a claim against the deceased’s estate under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.

However, the reason why the person was not provided for may also give cause for challenging the will.

In a recent case, a man who was excluded from benefiting from his father’s will, which was created three days before he died, brought a claim against the estate under the Act. The claim was settled by a consent order.

The man believed that his father’s will was invalid and claimed that his father lacked testamentary capacity (i.e. was not ‘of sound mind’) when the will was written, so he then went to court to have the will ruled invalid.

The executor of the will opposed his application on the basis that it would be inequitable and an abuse of process since the man had already obtained an agreed settlement. In effect, the argument was that the earlier consent order should stop him from having a second bite of the cherry.

On appeal, the court allowed the challenge to proceed: the payment to the son did not mean that he had accepted the validity of the will.

The contents of this article are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article.


Register for
our email

read more

Free Seminars
and Forums -
book your
place today

read more

Subscribe to
our blogs and
get all the news
as it’s added

read more

Who’s in
the news at

read more

Try our new
search facility to
find the lawyer
you need today!

read more

Latest News


Ian Copestake
Partner & Solicitor
01332 378 609
Personal Tax, Trusts, Wills and Probate
Richard Grosberg
Partner & Solicitor
0115 989 5219
Personal Tax, Trusts, Charities Group, Wills and Probate
Catherine McCannah
Partner & Solicitor
0115 851 1243
Trusts, Wills and Probate
Jane Sutherland
Partner & Solicitor
0116 214 6676
Personal Tax, Trusts, Wills and Probate


Craig Staten-Spencer
Associate & Trust Manager
0115 989 5251
Trusts, Personal Injury, Wills and Probate